in Computer Networks
13,118 views
25 votes
25 votes

Which one of the following statements is FALSE?

  1. Packet switching leads to better utilization of bandwidth resources than circuit switching
  2. Packet switching results in less variation in delay than circuit switching
  3. Packet switching requires more per-packet processing than circuit switching
  4. Packet switching can lead to reordering unlike in circuit switching
in Computer Networks
13.1k views

4 Comments

@set2018 can you please explain a bit more about datagram and virtual circuit approach?

0
0

The virtual circuit approach in Packet Switching is not used in the Internet.

It is majorly used in X.25 and Asynchronous Transfer mode.

 

So, by default consider the connectionless version of Packet Switching (Datagram approach)

4
4

5 Answers

51 votes
51 votes
Best answer

Answer is B.

In circuit switching, a fix bandwidth is allocated to each connection, e.g. $64$ $Kb/s$ allocated to each each phone call.

In circuit switching each connection has a dedicated circuit or channel all the way along the path and the circuit is not shared with anyone else.

Thus in circuit switching each call has its own private, guaranteed, isolated data rate from end to end.So we can say that every connection or flow is independent of others.

In the case of packet switching, all flows share the full channel capacity by statistical multiplexing.

So, the bandwidth allocated to each flow depends upon the number of concurrent flows & network traffic.

In packet switching if we know the type of link we are using, the bandwidth allocated, the packet size for any flow then we can calculate the Propagation Delay & Transmission Delays.

But, Queueing Delay is a random variable that depends upon the number of packets arriving at the same time at any switch.

It is the only random variable in our end to end delay expression.All other delays can be calculated precisely if we have enough information about the flows.

So, queueing adds unpredictable & variable delays in the packet switching.

There are delays like propagation delay etc. in circuit switching but they have a very small variance because of independence, privacy & bandwidth guarantees.

edited by

5 Comments

What does point c mean?

Pl explain...
2
2
Option B

Packet switching result in less variation in delay than circuit switching .it is wrong becouse packet switching data path is not unique.it is depending upon routing algorithm any instant of time. So in packet switching eavey path its own delay.so variation in dalay is more as compared to circuit switching because in cicuit switching all packet goes to same path so difference between packet delay is less.
19
19
In circuit switching processing is  done at time of connection established but data transfer phase simply data transfer.in packet switching data processed  every router like store data forward data according to routing algorithm. So option C is true.
5
5
What about congestion in circuit switching & packet switching? I think packet switching have more chance of congestion when compared to circuit switching?
0
0

i think packetization and transmission delay for all intermediate devices..
it stop and forward the packet.

0
0
100 votes
100 votes
A) in Circuit switching resources (path or in other words Bandwidth)are reserved , it's like suppose you have to reach Z from A and you have many paths and there are many other passengers who also have to reach Z from A. Here in circuit switching you choose some path prior to your journey and then say everyone , hello! you all i'm using this-this path and no one can use the same path , it's mine until i reach Z so in that way even if you don't utilize your path properly , no one can claim to snatch it from you..While in packet switching you're a friendly person , here you say , come on you all brothers we all have to reach Z and we will share paths. our Telephone connection follows circuit switching while Internet follows packet switching.

B)Here he is taking about the delay  between data units. in circuit switching as path is pre determined even before journey so during journey there are no interrupts like it's not an un-planned journey..everything is well planned while Packet switching is an unplanned journey , during the path you have to make many decisions like , now what path we should follow....IP is a connection less protocol so to get some reliability here Routers are Best effort delivery protocols when they receive any packet they store them for temp time and know the best path for them through routing table and them forward them to right interface.So this store and forward is kind of DELAY...which doesn't exist in circuit switching....

C)Here we have to focus carefully , what he is asking ...Circuit switching involve three steps to reach it's destination 1) connection establishment 2) data transfer 3) connection release while packet switching only involve one step 'data transfer' , no connection establishment and release step here  and it's quite common as there is no pre planned path...here he is not asking total time but he is asking per packet processing time , which means during traveling (Data transfer phase) and we know due to store and forward packet switching consume more time than circuit switching..

D) of course when packets are following different-2 paths , who know which packet will reach first ,,,so in that way may we they reach out of order...in circuit switching everything is in order...they only have to worry before journey to plan it , during journey they chill...

so B  is answer in that way...

4 Comments

Nice explanation. This should be the selected Answer !!!!!
0
0

@rohan30

check the times when those two answers were uploaded :)

0
0
this should be selected as best answer :)
0
0
5 votes
5 votes

To answer this question, we'd assume the default technique of Packet Switching, which is Datagram mode.


Packet switching leads to better utilization of bandwidth resources than circuit switching

Correct, Because in circuit switching, we have a dedicated connection (until it's termination), which will be reserved for the end machines even when they don't transfer data. This wastes bandwidth.

Since Packet Switching is connectionless, bandwidth isn't wasted on dedicated paths.

 

Packet switching results in less variation in delay than circuit switching

Incorrect. In Circuit switching, all the data is sent on the same, dedicated/reserved path. Ideally, all the data takes equal time to reach the destination.

Packet switching may forward packets via different paths (which will have different path lengths) and hence we'd observe a significant variation in delay.

 

Packet switching requires more per-packet processing than circuit switching

Correct. Each packet in packet switching goes through the "store and forward" phase at each switch, which requires higher cost/computation/processing.

 

Packet switching can lead to reordering unlike in circuit switching

Correct. Since each packet may take a different path to reach the destination in Packet switching, the packets taking the shorter paths will reach earlier.


Option B
2 votes
2 votes
B should be the answer
Answer:

Related questions